Why You Shouldn’t Pick Your Dog Up Around Other Dogs?

As dog owners, we often want to protect and comfort our furry companions in social situations, especially when they seem uneasy or threatened. 

One common reaction is to pick up our dogs when they encounter other dogs that appear aggressive or intimidating. 

However, while this gesture may come from a place of love and concern, it’s essential to understand that picking up your dog around other dogs can lead to unintended consequences. 

In this article, we will explore the reasons why this practice might not be the best idea, both for your dog’s well-being and for maintaining positive canine social interactions.

Miscommunication and Misinterpretation

Dogs communicate primarily through body language, vocalizations, and scent. 

When you pick up your dog in the presence of other dogs, you alter their body language and create a disconnect in the natural canine communication process. This disruption can lead to confusion and misinterpretation among the dogs involved.

For instance, a dog may approach your lifted pup with friendly intentions, but due to the elevation, your dog may perceive it as a threat. This can trigger fear-based responses and potentially escalate into aggressive behavior. 

Inadvertently, you may be sending signals that your dog is in distress, attracting unwanted attention from other dogs and causing a tense environment.

Reinforcing Fear and Anxiety

Picking up your dog in stressful situations can reinforce their fear and anxiety. Dogs are incredibly intuitive and can pick up on your emotions. 

See also  Where Do Indoor Dogs Go To The Toilet?

When you lift your dog to protect them, you inadvertently communicate that there is something to be afraid of, validating their fear response. 

This can make your dog more anxious and nervous in future social encounters, perpetuating a cycle of fear-based reactions.

Instead of picking up your dog, it’s better to provide positive reinforcement and encouragement when they exhibit calm and confident behavior. This will help build their self-assurance and ease their anxiety over time.

Impairing Social Skills Development

Just like humans, dogs need to learn how to interact appropriately with their peers. When you pick up your dog around other dogs, you deny them the opportunity to engage in social interactions and learn vital communication skills. 

Socializing with other dogs is crucial for a dog’s development, as it helps them understand boundaries, establish hierarchies, and learn proper play etiquette.

By allowing your dog to engage naturally with other dogs, you facilitate their social growth and increase the likelihood of developing positive relationships with their canine counterparts.

Aggravating Tension in Multi-Dog Households

In households with multiple dogs, picking up one dog and not the others can create a sense of favoritism and competition among the dogs. 

This can escalate into aggression or tension within the pack, as the picked-up dog may be perceived as receiving preferential treatment.

To maintain a harmonious household, it’s essential to treat all your dogs equally and provide consistent guidance and leadership.

Safety Concerns

Picking up your dog can be risky, especially if the other dog involved is reactive or aggressive. When you lift your dog, you put yourself in a vulnerable position, potentially exposing yourself to a dog bite or other injuries.

See also  Can you let a poodle air dry? Facts you should know

In situations where you feel the need to intervene, it’s best to use verbal commands or redirect your dog’s attention to a positive activity. This minimizes the risk of harm to both you and your furry friend.


While the instinct to protect your dog is understandable, picking them up around other dogs can lead to communication issues, reinforce fear and anxiety, hinder social development, and create tension in multi-dog households. 

Instead, focus on positive reinforcement, proper socialization, and fostering a confident and balanced canine companion.

Remember, understanding and respecting your dog’s natural instincts and communication is key to ensuring a safe and enjoyable experience for both your pet and other dogs they encounter. 

By allowing your dog to interact naturally with their peers, you contribute to their emotional well-being and contribute to a happier and healthier canine community overall.