Should I Pick My Dog Up If Another Dog Approaches?

As a responsible dog owner, it is essential to understand how to handle various situations that may arise while you are out with your furry companion. One common scenario dog owners often face is when another dog approaches their own. 

This situation can be both nerve-wracking and challenging to navigate. One option that might come to mind is to pick your dog up to prevent any potential issues. 

However, determining whether or not to pick up your dog in such situations requires careful consideration. In this article, we will explore the factors to consider and offer some guidance to help you make an informed decision.

Understanding Dog Behavior

Before delving into whether or not you should pick up your dog when another dog approaches, it is crucial to understand canine behavior. Dogs use body language and other cues to communicate with each other. 

Approaching another dog is a normal part of their social interaction. It allows them to exchange information and establish boundaries. However, not all dogs have the same temperament, and not every encounter is friendly.

Assessing the Situation

When another dog approaches your dog, it is important to assess the situation before taking any action. Consider the following factors:

Body Language: Observe the body language of both dogs. Are they exhibiting signs of friendliness, such as loose and relaxed body postures, wagging tails, and play bows? 

See also  Why do dogs run away when you try to pick them up?

Or do their postures appear tense, with raised hackles, fixed stares, or growling? Friendly interactions are generally harmless, while signs of aggression indicate a potentially risky situation.

Size and Strength: Assess the relative size and strength of the approaching dog compared to your own. If the approaching dog is significantly larger or stronger, picking up your dog may be a reasonable precautionary measure.

Familiarity: Consider whether your dog is familiar with the approaching dog. If they have previously interacted and displayed positive behavior, it might be safe to allow them to engage. However, if they have a history of negative encounters, it is better to err on the side of caution.

Context: Take into account the environment in which the interaction is occurring. If you are in a designated off-leash area or at a dog park with appropriate supervision, dogs may be more likely to engage in social play. 

However, if you are in an unfamiliar or potentially unsafe environment, picking up your dog could be a reasonable choice.

Potential Benefits of Picking Up Your Dog

In some situations, picking up your dog when another dog approaches may offer certain advantages:

Protection: Picking up your dog can provide a physical barrier between them and the approaching dog, reducing the risk of a negative interaction, particularly if the other dog shows signs of aggression.

Comfort: Some dogs may feel more secure when lifted off the ground, especially if they are anxious or fearful. Holding your dog can help alleviate their stress and prevent them from engaging in unwanted behavior.

See also  Should you take a toy away from a dog? Facts to check

Control: By picking up your dog, you gain more control over the situation. This can be particularly useful if you need to separate the dogs quickly or prevent any potential harm.

Potential Drawbacks of Picking Up Your Dog

While picking up your dog can be a protective measure, it also has potential drawbacks:

Encouraging Fear: Repeatedly lifting your dog whenever another dog approaches may reinforce their fear or anxiety. It can send a message that encounters with other dogs are inherently dangerous, which may hinder their socialization progress.

Aggravating Tension: If the approaching dog is displaying aggression, picking up your dog may escalate the situation. The lifted dog might become more vulnerable, triggering the other dog’s predatory instincts or intensifying its aggression.

Miscommunication: Dogs use body language to communicate, and by picking up your dog, you may interfere with their ability to express themselves. 

This interference can potentially lead to miscommunication and increase the risk of an unintended altercation.

Alternatives to Picking Up Your Dog

Instead of immediately resorting to picking up your dog, consider these alternative strategies:

Maintain Distance: Create space between your dog and the approaching dog by calmly walking away or changing your direction. This can help prevent any unwanted interactions without resorting to physical intervention.

Use Verbal Commands: Train your dog to respond to verbal commands such as “stay,” “sit,” or “leave it.” These commands can be useful in redirecting your dog’s attention and keeping them focused on you rather than the approaching dog.

Carry a Deterrent: Consider carrying a deterrent such as an umbrella, a walking stick, or a noise-making device that can help ward off an approaching dog without having to physically intervene.

See also  Why does my dog bring me a toy but not let me take it?


Deciding whether or not to pick up your dog when another dog approaches requires careful consideration of various factors such as body language, size, familiarity, and the context of the situation. 

While picking up your dog can offer protection and comfort, it is important to be mindful of the potential drawbacks and seek alternative strategies when appropriate. 

Ultimately, understanding your dog’s temperament, training, and individual needs will guide you in making the best decision for their safety and well-being.