Are Burglars Scared of Big Dogs? Owners should Know

Home security is a concern that’s shared by homeowners worldwide. From installing high-tech surveillance systems to reinforced doors and windows, people are constantly searching for ways to protect their homes and loved ones from potential threats. 

Among the various security measures, the presence of a loyal and protective furry friend often tops the list. The common belief is that burglars are scared of big dogs. 

But is this perception based on fact or fiction? In this article, we delve into the intriguing question: Are burglars really scared of big dogs, or is it just a myth?

The Myth of the Fearless Burglar

For years, popular culture has portrayed burglars as individuals who are skilled, fearless, and capable of navigating their way through complex security systems without breaking a sweat. Movies, TV shows, and even comic strips often depict these criminals as masterminds who are immune to ordinary deterrents. 

However, there’s one stereotype that’s been widely perpetuated: the fear of dogs, especially large and fierce breeds.

The Psychology Behind Canine Deterrence

To understand the dynamics between burglars and dogs, we need to delve into the psychology behind canine deterrence. Dogs, particularly large breeds, possess an innate sense of loyalty and protectiveness towards their human companions and their territory. 

This instinct has been honed through centuries of domestication, making dogs highly attuned to detecting and responding to potential threats.

See also  Is Irish Spring Safe for Dogs to Smell? Explained

When a burglar encounters a home guarded by a big dog, several psychological factors come into play. 

The first is the element of surprise. A barking or growling dog can startle an intruder, disrupting their initial plan and causing them to rethink their actions. This unexpected encounter can create a sense of panic and unease, making the burglar reconsider their decision to break into the property.

Moreover, dogs possess acute senses of smell and hearing. They can detect unfamiliar scents and sounds from a distance, giving them an advantage in alerting homeowners to potential threats. 

Burglars are aware of this heightened sensitivity, which can act as a powerful deterrent. The fear of being detected early by a vigilant dog can discourage burglars from targeting a property altogether.

Burglars’ Perspective: Do Dogs Really Scare Them?

To gain insights into the effectiveness of dogs as a deterrent, it’s crucial to consider the perspective of burglars themselves. While there isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer, interviews with reformed burglars provide valuable insights. 

Many burglars admit that the presence of a big dog does indeed give them pause. A study conducted by a home security company found that a staggering 85% of burglars surveyed reported that the presence of a dog, regardless of its size, would deter them from attempting a break-in.

Burglars often express concerns about the unpredictability of a dog’s behavior. Even if a dog appears friendly, its loyalty to its owners can lead it to defend its territory vigorously when it senses a threat. 

This unpredictability makes burglars hesitant to take their chances, as the potential consequences of encountering an aggressive dog far outweigh the potential rewards of the burglary.

See also  Are German Shepherds Better Than Pit Bulls? Explained

The Power of Perception

The perception of dogs as effective deterrents isn’t solely grounded in reality. Public perception plays a significant role in shaping burglars’ attitudes and decisions. As the myth of burglars being afraid of big dogs perpetuates, it can create a self-fulfilling prophecy. 

Homeowners who believe that their large dogs provide security are more likely to invest time and effort into training and socializing their pets, making them even more effective at deterring potential intruders.

Additionally, signage and visual cues, such as “Beware of Dog” signs or the presence of dog toys in the yard, contribute to the perception that a property is guarded by a fierce canine. These cues can lead burglars to assume that the risks associated with targeting such a property outweigh the potential rewards.

Factors that Influence Deterrence

While the presence of a big dog can be a significant deterrent, it’s important to acknowledge that several factors can influence its effectiveness. Training and socialization play a crucial role in determining how a dog responds to strangers. 

A well-trained dog that is socialized with various people and situations is less likely to become overly aggressive without cause. On the other hand, an untrained or aggressive dog can pose risks not only to potential intruders but also to innocent individuals.

Moreover, the breed of the dog can impact its perceived threat level. While larger breeds often have a more intimidating appearance, the demeanor of the dog matters more than its size. A small dog with a fierce temperament might be just as effective at deterring intruders as a large dog with a friendly disposition.

See also  Should I Bathe My Dog After Giving Birth? Explained


The age-old belief that burglars are scared of big dogs is not merely a myth; it is grounded in psychological and perceptual realities. The loyalty, protectiveness, and unpredictability of dogs, coupled with the power of public perception, contribute to the effectiveness of dogs as deterrents. 

While not an infallible solution, the presence of a well-trained and socialized big dog can indeed discourage burglars from targeting a property. However, it’s essential to recognize that no security measure is foolproof. 

While dogs can play a crucial role in enhancing home security, they should be part of a comprehensive approach that includes proper locks, alarms, and other deterrents. 

By understanding the dynamics between burglars and big dogs, homeowners can make informed decisions about how to best protect their homes and loved ones from potential threats.